Natural disasters wreck FinTech infrastructure, proving cash is still king

The lessons from recent hurricanes shouldn't be ignored. It’s time to upgrade internet infrastructure and position people to achieve financial sophistication.
The lessons from recent hurricanes shouldn't be ignored. It’s time to upgrade internet infrastructure and position people to achieve financial sophistication.

Hurricanes and other natural disasters remind us that our ambitious human efforts to build financial technologies and new forms of digital money can easily be rendered futile. Paying for Uber rides with a contactless card, trading Bitcoin, and using Venmo and Cash App to make purchases can often be a mechanical, effortless exercise. In a disaster zone, however, all of this is vanity. Surviving natural disasters requires citizens to spend money on food, water, and other basic necessities — and doing that without cash on hand is an unexpected and impossible dilemma.  

When natural disasters shatter banks and power grids, how do citizens in the storm’s path of destruction transact? How should communities prepare for financial meltdowns precipitated by Mother Nature? 

Natural disasters not only cause widespread destruction and trauma, they drive local economies to a dead halt. Based on survey evidence, Pew Research Center concluded that seven in 10 Americans (72%) reported at least one personal experience with extreme weather in 2024. The Federal Emergency Management Agency (FEMA) also reported that 81 major disaster declarations have already been made in 2024 so far, which is double the number that was recorded two years ago.

Related: Key takeaways from the Golden Boys’ attack on Compound DAO

One recent disaster — Hurricane Helene — made landfall and flooded remote parts of the Appalachian Mountains, causing “biblical devastation” and record-breaking levels of death and destruction not seen in the region since the historic flood of 1916. The catastrophic aftermath of the Category 4 behemoth left millions of Americans without internet, cell phone service, and electricity, mocking the ubiquitous availability of traditional financial payment rails and fintech digital infrastructures — which all went dark in an instant. Cell phones could not be used to send money to relatives. Computers could not be used to make purchases. No digital device could be charged in electrical outlets. Banks with FedNow instant payment services were closed or flooded.

Banking, Banks, Payments, Opinion

Seven in 10 Americans reported at least one personal experience with extreme weather in 2024. Source: Pew Research Center

The regional target of Hurricane Helene’s gravest impact — Appalachia — is significant: households in this rural region have fragmented access to broadband services compared to households nationally, which thereby hinders their access to online financial and banking services, especially during severe weather. Under these circumstances, only one option to transact payments exists — cash. As disaster relief organizations explain, cash offers the most flexibility to address urgent needs, and the influx of cash — largely through charitable donations — injects money back into local economies, helping local businesses and communities recover.

The financial impact of hurricanes and other natural disasters should be taken just as seriously as the emotional and physical. Experience is the best teacher, and Hurricane Helene has delivered three blunt lessons for every American to consider.

Related: Federal agencies are missing the mark on celebrity crypto endorsements

First, preserve the future of cash. Physical cash should never be phased out — a notion contrary to what experts believe will happen to the future of money given the rise in digital payments and popularity of digital currencies. Yet, citizens would be wise to keep some cash savings on hand, while local ATMs should be fully stocked and functional to keep cash dispersions fluid. 

Second, fix outdated internet capabilities. Local governments and public service organizations should invest in innovations like Starlink, which provides internet from space through a network of satellites in orbit around the Earth. Moving internet infrastructure into space reduces the threat of damage caused by catastrophic storms trudging through the troposphere, which often disables the functionality of cable networks, wires, and fiber optic cables. Although the realm of space orbit is not entirely safe — occasionally plagued by space debris, dust, and space weather phenomena — satellite-based connectivity on the ground adds legitimate lifelines in dangerous conditions.        

Third, support meaningful financial education. Financial well-being means having the ability to meet basic living needs, manage daily finances, be resilient to financial shocks, and plan for the future. Educating individuals about the importance of cash savings is equally important as guiding a hurricane victim through the process of accessing financial assistance, filing insurance claims, and taking steps to rebuild their financial future. Sophisticated investors should hedge investments in the event that internet connectivity prevents closing or changing live positions in the event of volatile market turndowns.     

As communities recover, unbanked and underbanked individuals who live in banking deserts — areas without a physical bank presence within a certain radius of a population — should consider fintech alternatives to bank accounts, such as GreenDot or Vanilla Direct. These companies enable users to load cash onto prepaid debit cards or mobile digital wallets to pay bills or make purchases.  

With the right preparation, local communities can mitigate the risk of emergency-related financial challenges when existing financial and fintech infrastructures fail. The lessons from Hurricane Helene should not be ignored: it’s time to upgrade internet infrastructure, position individuals to achieve financial sophistication, and remember that when disaster strikes, cash is still king.

Agnes Gambill West is a guest columnist for Cointelegraph, an associate professor at Appalachian State University and an attorney startup advisor. She serves on the Business and Consumer Payments Advisory Council for the Federal Reserve Bank of Richmond, is an advisor to the North Carolina Blockchain Initiative, and was appointed by the lieutenant governor of North Carolina as the vice chair of the North Carolina Innovation Council. She was previously a proprietary trader on Wall Street, the co-founder of an Ethereum-based blockchain company, and a visiting senior research fellow at the Mercatus Center. She received a JD from University of North Carolina School of Law, an LLM from Duke University School of Law, and an MSc from Oxford University.

This article is for general information purposes and is not intended to be and should not be taken as legal or investment advice. The views, thoughts, and opinions expressed here are the author’s alone and do not necessarily reflect or represent the views and opinions of Cointelegraph.