Update (Jan. 5 6:00 AM UTC): This article has been updated to add comments from Pons Asinorum.
During the holiday season, the founders of two nonfungible token (NFT) collections announced that they would be giving away company equity to NFT holders.
On Dec. 25, Pons Asinorum, founder of the NFT collection “The Plague,” announced that holders of their NFTs will be allocated a percentage of company shares based on the number of unlisted NFTs they hold.
On Christmas morning The Plague NFT gave to me....
— Pons Asinorum (@Pons_ETH) December 25, 2023
Equity (shares) in their company!
Yes, you read that right. Real shares, in our company.
Every Frog NFT holder as of 10 minutes ago will be allocated a percentage of shares based on the number of unlisted frogs they are… pic.twitter.com/zHVqeq4dyt
While it might look like there may be legal and regulatory risks involved, the NFT founder claimed it was legal as the shares were not sold. The founder said that they consulted multiple lawyers over the legalities of the move and said that holders did not expect to receive shares when they bought their NFTs.
In a statement to Cointelegraph, Pons said he did this because he wanted to “give a gift to the community” that helped them build their brand. He also believes it’s legal and explained that it was completely unexpected. Pons said nobody, except his legal team, knew it would happen. Pons wrote:
“There was no expectation that they would get equity, and they did not have to do anything to receive the equity. It was a gift. No different than if I gifted shares to my friends and family.”
Days after the announcement, another founder of a popular NFT collection announced a similar move. On Jan. 1, Rektguy co-founder Ovie Faruq, also known as OSF in the NFT space, announced that their NFT holders would be gifted equity in their company, Rekt Brands Inc.
On 4th December 2023 we announced that a surprise snapshot of Rektguy holders was taken on 12AM EST on 26th October 2023.
— OSF (@osf_rekt) January 1, 2024
We are delighted to reveal that holders at the time of snapshot will be gifted equity in our company, Rekt Brands Inc.
Rekt Brands owns and controls… pic.twitter.com/twPkwrnfvt
The executive said this is a gift to collectors who supported Rektguy as an art project. Faruq also clarified that trading the NFTs will not transfer any equity. The Rektguy co-founder also implied that this was being done legally. “We are proud of our work behind the scenes to achieve this in a valuable and compliant way.”
According to NFT tracker CryptoSlam, The Plague has an all-time sales volume of over $7 million, while Rektguy has over $28 million.
Related: Early Mickey Mouse version becomes top NFT on OpenSea after copyright expires
Community members reacted to the announcements, discussing whether the moves were a “gamechanger or just a sham.” Azuki’s researcher-in-residence, Waleswoosh, believes this is legal “under certain circumstances.”
The researcher said that in both cases, the criteria for eligibility are already in the past. Waleswoosh explained that the NFTs were not sold with the clear intention of offering equity.
Meanwhile, some expressed their hopes that other brands would understand its implications. A community member said there could be multiple ways to apply it and circle around real equities. “The most realistic one is NFTs/Trait market share: you generate sales and a % goes to a specific holder,” they wrote.
Cointelegraph reached out to Faruq on X but did not get a response.
Magazine: Asia Express: First digital yuan wallet seizure, China’s $10B Web3 fund, Starbucks NFTs